“We had Nick’s cater for our Irish wedding (because, well, let’s face it, Italian food is just more flavorful than Irish food). We got SO many compliments on the food and people went back for seconds and thirds. Anthony was friendly and easy to work with when we placed our catering order and the food was just what we hoped it would be. We were so happy to give business to a local, family-run establishment! Thank you, Nick’s, for helping to make our day so special.”

– Erin Pixley Thurston

By The Pan

Full serves 20 | Half serves 10

Oven Roasted Chicken $95 full | $55 half

BBQ Chicken $100 full | $60 half

Chicken French w/ Escarole $110 full | $65 half

Chicken Parmesan $105 full | $65 half

Chicken French $100 full | $60 half

Chicken Marsala $100 full | $60 half

Italian Sausage w/ Peppers & Onions $90 full | $55 half

Roast Beef Au Jus $95 full | $55 half

Pulled Pork $95 full | $55 half

Maple Ham $90 full | $55 half

Homemade Meatballs $70 full | $40 half

Fettuccini Alfredo $85 full | $55 half

Penne Vodka $85 full | $55 full

Baked Ziti $75 full | $50 half

Lasagna $100 full | $60 half

Gnocchi $85 full | $55 half

Eggplant Parmesan $95 full | $60 half

Greens & Beans $75 full | $45 half

Fried Calamari $95 full | $60 half

Oven Roasted Potatoes $60 full | $40 half

Garlic Mashed Potatoes $55 full | $35 half

Tossed Salad $55 full | $35 half

Mac Salad $55 full | $35 half

Assorted Cold Cut Platters/Party Trays

SM (serves 15) $50 | MED (serves 25) $75 | LRG (serves 35) $99

Homemade Rolls $7.49/dozen
 

Dessert Trays

Assorted Mini Pastries (2) $3.99pp

Includes cannolis and eclairs

Italian Cookie Trays $3.99pp

3 cookies per person

 

Other

  • Chafing dishes are available to rent at only $30 per buffet (includes Sterno for hot foods).
  • Serving utensils for you to keep are available at $10 per buffet.
  • For all buffets add $2 per person for under 30 people. The minimum for a buffet is 10 people.
  • Plates, bowls, cups, napkins, & silverware are available for an additional $1.50 per person.
  • $200 minimum order for all deliveries.
  • $25 delivery fee for all deliveries in Monroe County.
  • 5% gratuity – up to $50 will be added to your bill for all deliveries.

Buffets

Nick’s Party Plate

Includes Rolls & Butter, Macaroni Salad, Our Famous Meat Hot Sauce, Spicy Mustard, Onions & Ketchup On The Side

Also Choice Of Meat:
2 Cheeseburgers
2 Hamburgers
2 Hot Dogs OR 1 Burger & 1 Hot Dog
Choice Of One: Home Fries Or French Fries

$14/person

Italian

Includes Rolls & Butter, Tossed Salad, Chicken Parmesan, Italian Sausage With Sweet Peppers & Onions, Greens & Beans, Oven Roasted Potatoes & Baked Ziti

$16.95/person

Western Style Picnic

Includes Rolls, Baked Beans, Salt Potatoes, Macaroni Salad

Also Choice Of Two:
BBQ Ribs
BBQ Chicken
Hots & Hamburgers
BBQ Roast Beef
Pulled Pork
Italian Sausage With Sweet Peppers & Onions

$15.95/person

Deluxe

Includes Rolls & Butter, Tossed Salad, Oven Roasted Potatoes, Baked Ziti, Greens & Beans

Also Choice Of Two:
Chicken French
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Parmesan
Oven Roasted Chicken In Wine Sauce
Pulled Pork
Baked Ham
Italian Sausage With Sweet Peppers & Onions
Roast Beef Au Jus
Each Additional Meat Add $3.50/Person

$16.95/person

Party

Includes Rolls & Butter, Tossed Salad, Oven Roasted Potatoes, Baked Ziti

Also Choice Of One:
Chicken French
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Parmesan
Oven Roasted Chicken In Wine Sauce
Pulled Pork
Baked Ham
Italian Sausage With Sweet Peppers & Onions
Roast Beef Au Jus
Each Additional Meat Add $3.50/Person

$13.95/person